SCMP Letters | Give workers protection, not just resilience training
Updated: 16 hours ago
A recent survey identified Hong Kong’s Generation Y, or those aged 30 to 45, as the city’s unhappiest age group. I welcome the health secretary’s written reply last week to a legislator’s questions about the government’s mental health strategy, but would like to point out the limitations of two of the measures he mentioned.
The first is resilience training. A Chinese University study funded by the government’s Mental Health Initiatives Funding Scheme examined an eight-week resilience programme involving 143 parents of autistic children. It found no significant improvement overall: only the moderately stressed benefited, while the most stressed did not. Training alone cannot remove the pressures people face.
The second is the Mental Health Workplace Charter, signed by more than 3,400 organisations by end-September. The charter is voluntary, its action items are mostly talks and information sharing, and it has no complaint channel, investigation procedure or outcome indicator.
When people describe being belittled at work, the response they need is not being told everyone is under pressure.
Generation Y’s unhappiness has many causes, but how people are treated at work is one that the law can address. Hong Kong’s anti-discrimination ordinances do not cover workplace bullying as a stand-alone category. Taiwan’s new legal provision on workplace bullying prevention, in force since July, requires employers to establish complaint and investigation mechanisms. A statutory obligation gives employers a reason to learn how to speak to people. Hong Kong should do the same for its workers. Employees need a way to report mistreatment and have it investigated, not another invitation to become more resilient.
Raymond Yang Sze-ngai, co-founder and executive director, Just Feel




Comments